Subtitling, one of the underresearched topics in translation studies, is a challenging task faced by many restrictions that compel subtitlers to use specific strategies to enhance the quality of the subtitles. Issues of culture specific item translation in subtitling. The system lets you keep clientvendor database, with contacts and rates, manage projects and assign jobs to vendors, issue invoices, track payments, store and manage project files, generate business reports on turnover profit per clientmanager etc. Questioni pratiche e teoriche, ma thesis, universita degli studi di trieste, sc. Subtitling cultural specificity from english to chinese. In his introduction to topics in audiovisual translation, philip orero claims that subtitling calls for an enourmous variety of skills x. These are retention, specification, direct translation, generalization, substitution, omission or the use of an official equivalent. Subtitling, as all other types of audiovisual translation, has always been influenced by cultural factors, and in turn subtitles have influenced their target readers. Reading speed is the relation between the duration of a subtitle and the number of characters that it can contain so that it can. The data make it possible to explore the different stages of the subtitling process and the time spent on each task, and to compare the techniques used by subtitling trainees and professionals when they face translation problems.
The term itself, with all the existing varieties cultural words newmark, 1988. Subtitling dubbing sweden subtitling subtitling table over the common use of subtitling and dubbing, respectively. The process of subtitling the phases you must follow. This poses questions as to how people perceive these subtitles, and if and how their reading of l2 subtitles differs from their reading of l1 subtitles. To what extent the strategies that gottlieb offered in his subtitling typology are applicable into the persiantoenglish subtitling. This focus or limitation on certain aspects of translation is expected to help the researcher to have a deeper understanding on translation technique and to help the watcher figure out the story of the movie and understand the meaning of the lyrics. A printed translation of foreignlanguage dialogue shown at the bottom of the. However, she has tried to combine into her typology.
In the scandinavian subtitles project, some 2500 source text st ecrs of interest have been extracted, giving more than 5000 examples of translation solutions. Some examples of the extent of usage of dubbing and subtitling respectively. Although the existing classifications of the culturebound words are quite numerous for example, newmark, 1988. In the light of an examination of the generic features of audiovisual translation and of the particular cultural constraints inherent in translation for arabicspeaking. Using process methods to study subtitling david orregocarmona1, lukasz stanislaw dutka2, agnieszka szarkowska2 1 university of the free state, south africa 2 institute of applied linguistics, university of warsaw first south african interuniversity translation and interpreting conference. The paper employs the taxonomy designed by pedersen 2011 for culture specific item translation from english into lithuanian analyzed in the subtitles of the australian tv reality show my kitchen rules.
Omission is one of the strategies employed in subtitling some culturebound expressions. Once a corporate culture is established, it provides employees with identity and stability, which in turn provide the corporation with commitment. It is essential to have native speakers producing subtitle translations that understand the culture, humour, etiquette and quirks of the language, making careful and thought out word. Texts, translation and subtitling in theory, and in denmark henrik gottlieb, university of copenhagen general outline the aim of this paper is to focus systematically on the many faces of translation, part i, and to give special attention to one of these faces. Linguistic, cultural and technical problems in englisharabic. Subtitling is also a relevant field of research because of the technical problems that are involved, many of which will be discussed later on.
Subtitling cultural specificity from english to chinese dayan liu chongqing jiaotong university school of foreign languages no. A secondary, usually explanatory title, as of a literary work. A formerly binding polish norm permitted two lines and thirtytwo characters per line of subtitle, with at least eight frames between two subsequent subtitles. Subtitling definition of subtitling by the free dictionary. That brings about some dubbing in countries subtitling is the predominant alternative. In the light of an examination of the generic features of audiovisual translation and of the particular cultural constraints inherent in.
I would like to see a section in the nssa subtitling pdf that addresses music lyrics and when to include them or not. Introduction, 251 subtitling strategies in european countries, 252 background information, 253 chao ji gong min connection by fate, 254 case study chao ji gong min connection by fate, 257 languagebound problems, 259 culture. A model is proposed, wherein all strategies available to the subtitler are listed. Total of 10 weeks teaching with 2 hours classroom contact per week consisting of a 1 hour lecture and a 1 hour. Im a student of translation studies and i need some information about strategies applied for translating culturebound elements. The translated subtitle must not exceed the length and duration of the time that is available for example, the number of frames.
A proposed set of subtitling standards in europe 1998 thread tools. Strategies used for translating culturebound elements. There are many technical problems in subtitling such as the average. On the other hand, a strong culture, with wellordered values, beliefs, and assumptions may hinder efforts at change, especially in a merger or takeover. The limitations you have in the process of subtitling. The author discusses strategies available to the subtitlers confronted with such phenomena in films. Subtitling process research the process of subtitling. Rendering culture specific items in an audiovisual format is currently one of the most topical issues in translation research. Abstract this study investigates the problems that translators tend to face in the subtitling and dubbing of englishlanguage films and television programmes into arabic and suggests solutions for these problems. Ive read on the internet that the bestknown investigation was made by. Vlahov, florin, 1980, they are not necessarily relevant in terms of the subtitled transfer, which, however, could benefit significantly from one particular distinction.
The model also investigates the subtitling process, in that the parameters that. Code of good subtitling practice subtitle spotting and translation. Culturebound problems culturebound problems are often mentioned and described, both in literature on subtitling and on translation in general. Bibliography of subtitling and related subjects for a long. The process of defining the in and out times of individual subtitles so that they are synchronised with the audio, and adhere to the minimum and maximum duration times, taking the shot changes into consideration. Introduction this paper is a preliminary work that comes from the interest aroused in subtitling as a conveying element and as cultural transfer content. Issues and strategies of subtitling cultural references harry potter. To what extent the strategies that gottlieb offered in his subtitling typology are. Subtitling an issue of speed 4 but, under observation, respondents did not easily distinguish between the different subtitling speeds of the programme clips shown to them, especially between 160 and 180 words per minute.
This is probably particularly true in the case where strategies combine. This study examined the effectiveness of english l2 subtitles by presenting native speakers of afrikaans with subtitles. This paper will combine the existing translation theories to analyze the reasons causing the nonequivalence from the chineseenglish cultural levels. This article aimed to investigate to what extent the gottlieb model of translation strategies for subtitling was ap. Subtitlers must always work with a copy of the production and, if possible, a dialogue list and glossary of atypical words and special references. When culturebound elements are dis cussed in relation to translation, the term will often refer to the nonlinguistic sphere, to different phenomena or events that exist in the source language culture. When a subtitler encounters an ecr in a st, she has several strategies at.
European languages and beyond moves in both of these directions and transcends the borders of the european languages to which the series is primarily though not exclusively addressed, to open itself up to a confrontation and reflection on other languages and cultures. The quality of live subtitling improving the viewer experience 1 section 1. This means that subtitling could involve a good amount of paraphrasing. Issues and strategies of subtitling cultural references. Laying the technical groundwork working from an image file and a dialogue list, a spotting technician uses specialized software to break down the dialogue and onscreen text that might need subtitling into segments, and locate where each subtitle should begin and end. Abstract in south africa subtitles are predominantly received as second language l2 text. In subtitling, as in all forms of interlingual transfer, this may cause problems in rendering culture.
Indicates the strategies used by subtitlers when confronted by these phenomena. Subtitling subtitling is the written translation of the spoken language source language of a television program or film into the language of the viewing audience the target language the translated text usually appears in two lines at the foot of the screen hassanpuor, 2008. Translation is an activity of enormous importance in the modern world and has become an established area in language studies, being the main criterion for achieving communication. Extralinguistic culture bound reference ecr, with particular focus on subtitling. Extralinguistic culturebound reference ecr, with particular focus on subtitling. They can either be a form of written translation of a dialog in a foreign language, or a written. Even road signs, billboards, and anything else written onscreen that is relevant to the story and will help the viewer understand the plot. The process of subtitling consists of the following phases. This introduction to subtitling has been written by the mondo agit agency subtitling is a type of audiovisual translation that has its own specifications, rules and criteria. The close interrelation between language and culture in interlingual subtitling may raise problems, or. However, in poland expectancy norms in subtitling are virtually nonexistent, due to the lack of a national subtitling standard and very little tradition to date.
Larsen culturebound problems in subtitling free download as pdf file. These are retention, specification, direct translation, generalization, substitution, omission or. When culture bound elements are dis cussed in relation to translation, the term will often refer to the nonlinguistic sphere, to different phenomena or events that exist in the source language culture. Durham etheses issues in the subtitling and dubbing. Inaccurate translations reveal the mismatches in beliefs and cultural norms between the western cultures and the arab culture. Ocelot isabel comitre narvaez university of malaga 1. This study investigates the problems that translators tend to face in the subtitling and dubbing of englishlanguage films and television programmes into arabic and suggests solutions for these problems. The study also identifies the subtitling strategies used by arab translators to solve the technical, linguistic and cultural problems of translating humour in seinfeld, and it uncovers the. About europe pmc funders joining europe pmc governance roadmap outreach. The present study investigates issues in the subtitling of humour in the american sitcom, seinfeld. Translation of extralinguistic cultural references in the english.
Would like to see a section in the nssa subtitling pdf listing subtitling shortcuts, keyboard shortcuts not available on the timer, spacing between html tags that result in the desired visual effect for the dominant viewing apps. It is the subtitlers job to spot the production and translate and write the subtitles in the foreign language required. Problems that translators face when they subtitle culturally. Durham etheses issues in the subtitling and dubbing of. Laying the technical groundwork working from an image file and a dialogue list, a spotting technician uses specialized software to break down the dialogue and onscreen text that might need subtitling into segments, and. Im a student of translation studies and i need some information about strategies applied for translating culture bound elements. Nedergaardlarsen, birgit 1993, culturebound problems in subtitling, in perspectives. Culture bound problems culture bound problems are often mentioned and described, both in literature on subtitling and on translation in general. The subtitler opts to delete the st expression and he may or may not compensate for it.
A subtitle has a minimum duration of a second and a maximum duration of 6 or 7 seconds on screen. Cultural difficulties in translations from english into arabic roxana s mares. Discusses the difficulty in rendering culturespecific or languagespecific elements in film subtitled translations of dialogue. A proposed set of subtitling standards in europe 1998. Discusses the difficulty in rendering culture specific or languagespecific elements in film subtitled translations of dialogue. Above 180wpm respondents were more likely to find the subtitles too fast, and more difficult to follow. Different ways of facing otherness chapter pdf available january 2004 with 1,561 reads how we measure reads. Translation is an activity of enormous importance in the modern world and has become an established area in. Sex is one of the taboo areas in the arabic culture, and therefore subtitlers tend to omit some of them when possible. The first thing to do before exploring the world of subtitling is to understand that this type of translation belongs to subordinate translation. To what extent the strategies that gottlieb offered in his. Pdf issues of culture specific item translation in subtitling. Translating such culturebound terms is challenging on all levels.
718 968 1329 314 1373 1031 461 325 409 105 105 845 393 184 682 640 555 937 885 82 998 680 358 365 1179 1338 128 955 365 904 1366 680 775 401 556 1473 674 1276 107 1198 489 1326 725 1112 861 1152